Overview – Products and Treatments for Chronic Pain
There are many treatment modalities for treating pain. Some are over the counter (OTC) drugs (e.g., Tylenol®, Motrin®, Aleve and topical products (e.g., Icy Hot®, Salonpas® and BioFreeze® pain relief patches, Bengay® and Aspercreme®). They can provide short-term pain relief (6-12 hours) and thus impractical for treating chronic pain. and ineffective in treating severe pain Others such as narcotics (e.g., Oxycontin®) are effective in some people but the risk of addiction make them problematic. There are more invasive treatments such as steroid injections, surgery, and implantable neurostimulation devices. They carry risks of infection, nerve injury, and damage to the spine. Manipulative approaches such as acupuncture, physical therapy, and chiropractic care, are effective in some chronic pain patients.
Drugs
The pain reliever acetaminophen (Tylenol®) is not effective for severe pain and cannot be used long-term due to risks of liver failure. Drugs such as non-steroid anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs; Motrin® and Aleve®) and corticosteroids have serious side effects with long-term use which limit their use in treating chronic pain. The risks include gastrointestinal bleeding, kidney damage, hypertension, fluid retention, and in rare cases, stroke and heart attack. Oral corticosteroids are associated with many serious side effects, including hypertension, diabetes, bone loss and many others which are exacerbated with long-term use.
Narcotics (e.g., Oxycontin®) are only minimally effective for treatment of chronic and severe pain. They carry significant risks of addiction and other major clinical problems. Approximately 25% of chronic pain patients are taking opioids and one in five of them will become addicted to these drugs. A number of anti-convulsant drugs have also been used to treat chronic pain including Gabapentin®, Neurontin®, and Lyrica®, but clinical studies have not demonstrated that they are effective. Anti-depressants are also used in patients to address depression as well as to treat their pain.
Pain Relief Patches
Over the counter (OTC) pain relief patches include Icy Hot®, Salonpas®, and BioFreeze®. These patches use drugs or other chemicals, such as lidocaine, methyl salicylate (Salonpas®), camphor or menthol. They are primarily used to treat acute pain since their therapeutic effects only last for 8 hours. In addition, they are used for mild to moderate pain and not severe pain. These products are thus rarely used for treating chronic pain.
There are three prescription pain relief patches on the market. One of these contains the narcotic Fentanyl and has risks of addiction. Lidoderm® is a Lidocaine patch approved to treat shingles and has modest therapeutic effects. A third patch is Qutenza® that contains the counterirritant, capsaicin, and works through a similar mechanism as BackVive. Lidoderm and Qutenza are not FDA approved and primarily used to treat neuropathic pain due to shingles and diabetic neuropathy. They are rarely used to treat chronic pain due to musculoskeletal disorders.
Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation (TENS)
Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) is also used to treat pain. It uses a device that contains wires that are attached to the skin. The device generates electricity which stimulates the skin over painful areas. Clinical studies have shown mixed results with the treatment, and it is relatively ineffective for treating severe pain. The devices are relatively large and also challenging to use. It must be adjusted by the patient on an ongoing basis to provide the optimal electrical stimulation and it must be worn continuously on the body.
Manipulative Therapies
Acupuncture is used for a variety of musculoskeletal conditions with modest benefits documented in some clinical studies, while others show no effects. Physical therapy can be effective in a subset of patients with back and neck pain. Other modalities include therapeutic massage and chiropractic manipulation which are unproven by clinical studies. None of these therapeutic modalities have demonstrated efficacy in treating severe pain.
Invasive Procedures
There are several invasive procedures to treat pain. Injection of steroids is common (15 million people) and used to treat back, knee, neck and back pain. However, clinical studies have only shown short-term benefit in a subset of patients. Similarly, spinal surgeries are performed in many patients, but clinical studies have shown mixed results. All of these procedures carry risks including infection, nerve injury, and spinal damage.
Dr. Ron's Thoughts
Chronic pain greatly varies among people suffering from this condition. Some people have mild pain for only a few months a year while others suffer from ongoing severe pain every day. Some have it in only one location, while many suffer from pain at several locations in the body. Sometimes, it starts with an injury while in others it is due to an underlying condition. Sorting all of this out requires the help of trained healthcare professionals that could put together a pain management plan that fits with your personal situation. This includes assessing benefits and risks of treatments and also their costs. The plan will likely involve a mix of therapeutic approaches that can work together to help you manage your condition.
The content should not be copied or reproduced without written permission.